2/28 Note: I'm not playing Blog Hookey - typed that twice as "Hockey"...where my fingers automatically go - I'm just waiting for the increased traffic Alan's Revival taping has generated here to return to regular levels before going on to the next entry. And his taping is sure important enough to warrant the pause. The wait and a few of the comments made here the past few days have given me plenty of time to think about what to say next; I think I'm finally going to get around to some speciic ideas about solo shows. Guess it's high time to start writing.
All done now. I'm sorry it took me so long. One lesson I have surely learned is that the more important it is, the more it matters, the more I care...the greater the challenge of writing it down. Words don't come easy, you see.
For reasons of varying validity, it's taken me far too long to finish up with CMT's filming of Alan Doyle: LIve At Revival. Not because it hasn't been on my mind. Just the opposite - I've awakened to a brand new beautiful Alan Doyle song every morning this past week and gladly sung those songs all day long; the most beautiful of his brand new songs, Rules Will All Be Broken, played on repeat in my mind throughout a rather rough appointment on Monday and very likely will again this afternoon at the second such appointment - but because getting the photos and video frames sorted and edited has been a laboriously slow process, and then there was travel and those appointments and other commitments that peskily insisted on claiming their unfair share of my time and attention.
There was nonsense too, the same old stupid mean shit (done by the same old stupid mean bullies, for the most part) that I shouldn't have let delay me for a moment, let alone for a day or two. Foolish of me, far more foolish than any bully because, unlike those bullies, I know the Truth. I know what matters here.
I know Who this is really all about.
View of the Boy, View from his Bridge.
In a world full of tired eyes,
Yours are still bright and true... - Alan Doyle
Every now and again, the significance of the moment is recognised while we are still in that moment. This is the Step Forward; there's no going back from Here. That's my best description of the CMT Live At Revival taping. There was Alan, standing in the middle of that pile of film equipment, standing out there with the amazing group of players he'd brought together and who in the space of three days he had formed into a Band, his own Dream Band, there to support him and his new music. There he was, handling every aspect of the filming process with sure-handed competence and ease, not with the usual nervous tension I've seen in him every other time at these filmed shows. Not this time, not at all. Not with these songs.
There was Alan, confidently performing his beautiful new songs with his amazing new band, songs that are open and honest, immediate and sincere, thoughtful and passionate, vulnerable and real. Songs that are loving and genuine and sweet - songs of himself, the strongest and most powerful and best of himself. Unforgettable melody lines, lovely instrumentation, and striking lyrics that tell a True Story - from the heart and to the heart. For the heart.
It was wonderful; he was wonderful, as wonderful as he truly is. Alll the while, the cameras were rolling. No, Alan, there is no going back from this.
And that is Most Wonderful of all.
I'm Sorry (with Hawksley Workman)
Break My Fall (with Hawksley Workman and Jim Cuddy)
It Ain't Enough
Lay Me Down
My Day
Break It Slow
(I Don't Mind Dancin' With You - impromptu)
Light The Way
A Heart Worth Breaking (Alan on piano)
Rules Will All Be Broken
Where I Belong
Some of these titles are, of course, purely speculative, and there's no saying which songs will make the final cut and be shown on the CMT show, which will also include a documentary portion about the makng of the album.
I know this is going to disappoint some folks who would have dearly loved to be at the taping, but I've (finally) decided not to put up any more videos, not yet. The songs are beautiful and wonderful and that makes the decision so difficult (especially with Rules Will All Be Broken), but I will not risk doing anything, however small, that could interfere with how Alan wants to debut his songs, whether on this show or some place else of his choosing. When the show airs, I'll put up what video I have as a Behind The Scenes point of view.
But since it's his songs I'm protecting, that means the video frames are fair game. Middle Ground, as it were.
The Alan Doyle Band (and Guests) - Some of these photos/video frames aren't the greatest quality since nearly all of them were taken from the KneeCam (we kinda sorta weren't supposed to be using cameras after the first song). My knee had quite the interesting vantage point: a wonderfully clear view of Alan (I could not have asked for a better or more appreciated view) but a bit tricky to see - that is, for my knee to "see" - some of the other players on the other side of the piano and the drum kit.
I also had an excellent view of the keyboards and an utterly fascinating view of Kris; after God only knows how many GBS shows, I finally got to see what he's doing back there...and to hear just how frigging loud those drums of his are.
Alan Doyle, Kendel Carson, Jim Cuddy
Alan Doyle, Kendel Carson, Jim Cuddy
Cory Tetford, Alan Doyle, Kendel Carson, Hawksley Workman
(Peekaboo) Kris Macfarlane, Derrick Brady
It was a splendid band playing in support of Alan's spectacular performance.
During Light The Way and It Ain't Enough, I kept thinking about Alan playing the High School Hockey Dances. I really loved that thought.
Rules Will All Be Broken could be the most beautiful song I have ever heard; so says my heart. Worth waiting eleven years for; worth waiting a lifetime for.
Yes, you are. Absolutely. Always and forever.
It's time for that second rough appointment. It's time for your song.
*****************************************************************************************************************************
It worked, again. Alan has written a powerfully beautiful song.
While waiting outside the Revival Bar to be let in for the taping, we could hear soundcheck/rehearsal going on but couldn't see much of how the venue was set up. When we were let in and directed to our seats - again, much credit to the CMT production staff for smoothly and efficiently shepherding all of us safely across an obstacle course of instruments, mics, wires and cameras and to the various places in which they chose to put us - it still took me a minute or two to sort out the arrangement of mics and figure out that the band would be playing in a circle, facing inward toward one another.
That set me to puzzling out who would be at which mic. Since we were basically sitting between the drum kit and the piano, it was pretty clear where Kris and Todd would be. I found the bass and the fiddle - Derrick and Kendel thus located too. That put Alan at the top of the circle, directly across from where we were sitting. Which made sense, given the bank of Big Cameras and all the sound equipment that was right behind us. There were also some handheld cameras behind the bar to our left, but no cameras at al down at the other end of the room, where the majority of the audience members had been seated.
He's going to play with his back to most of the audience, I realised suddenly. His performance will be to the other players and for the cameras. Whoever made that call, it was brilliant. This was a showcase for Alan's songs, not a concert. As delighted as all of us were to be there for the taping, this performance wasn't about those in the studio audience; instead, it was about introducing Alan's Solo Album to each and every person who will watch the CMT show when it airs nationwide.
While Alan had - and of course made the most of - ample opportunity to be his usual endearing self with the audience members, chatting up and thoroughly charming the folks behind him in-between songs and while retrieving and tuning his instruments, when it came time for his songs, those songs got his full focus and undivided attention. And his whole heart. His was a magnificent performance, subtle and nuanced, commanding and sure, poignant and seductive - every moment in perfect consonance with each song and for each song - him courting the camera like a bold and tender lover confident of his welcoming embrace.
From the first moment he came out, greeted by louder applause than I thought humanly possible from such a small group of people, I looked up into his face and could see that he knew - knew that this was going to be special, knew it was going to be worth the long wait, knew he was going to make the most of his wonderful new songs.
And he was right about that. He was right about all of it. I love it when he's right.
You never know what will and what won't make the cut in the final edit of a filmed show. There were some great comments made between the songs, some of them funny (Alan's mentions of how attractive his Mom finds Cory and Kris's tongue-in-cheek - and longsuffering - "Tempo's not my job" quip) and some were sweet (in particular Hawksley's much-appreciated-by-me remark that "No one works harder, no one is smarter, no one is funnier than Alan Doyle").
I hope a bit of broadcast time is set aside to show how thoughtful and kind Alan was with his band members, asking them solicitously if they were alright, if they needed any water, if all was well. He's a good band leader, the sort of leader who makes you willing and glad to follow him.
I hope most of all that CMT shows enough of Alan's between-song demeanour to make it clear just how steady and sure and poised he was throughout the filming. He was the Man who knows full well the measure of himself and the worth of his songs, the Man who believes enough in himself and his music to be both serious and sincere. He was Alan. It was wonderful to see him there.
I doubt the cameras were running during the equipment issues with Todd's organ when Alan started in on the breathlessly beautiful not-yet-ready-for-live-performance I Don't Mind Dancin' With You, an expertly written tune in which resides this sparkling jewel of a lyric:
I've been around
The wrong side of town
So long that it feels right to me
Truly perfect and perfectly true. I can't wait to hear this song on the album and in the live shows too, along with all the rest of Alan's Boy On Bridge songs. The richness and depth of the 10 songs performed for the LIve At Revival show are deeply impressive in their own right; knowing that even more is yet to come on this album - again, it's difficult to say just how many songs will be on Boy On Bridge, but at last count, Alan was talking about more than 15, perhaps as many as 18 - has me over the moon about this album.
However Alan's songs wind up being arranged and performed - there will be the studio arrangements and then the live-show arrangements, with the latter possibly varying if it turns out he has different band members with him at different times, these CMT-show live versions likely being one of those several arrangements - the Constant will be the songs themselves, them and the Man, the Boy On Bridge, who has created them. They are such good songs, honest and strong, true songs that encompass and embody a real-world emotional landscape: love, regret, hope, loss, delight, fear, need, passion. And the wealth of sweetness that's there to be discovered and treasured in the heart of that Boy.
There will be so much more to say about Alan's songs when his Solo Album is released, as well as when the live shows begin. For now, just a bit about the songs as heard at Revival:
From I'm Sorry (co-written with Hawksely Workman, who joined Alan's band for this song), a hauntingly melancholy chorus:
You can't unring a bell
You can't untell a story
You can't unbreak a heart,
I'm sorry, I'm sorry
I love how this one opens, with Alan quite literally "banging his own drum," then playing the guitar long enough to set the track and next switching to the mandolin. I also love the Jackson Browne echo of the melody line when he sings "Fast forward to the broken heart..." Most of all, I love how painfully true this song is, how openly it accepts the consequences it so achingly wishes it could be spared.
Close proximity to the drums made it difficult to hear much more other than those drums in Alan's second song, another Hawksley co-write, on which both Hawksley and Jim Cuddy joined in. I'm calling it Break My Fall because that was a repeating lyric and central theme in what played as a gentle, hopeful, wistfully longing love song.
It Ain't Enough is pure energy, pure drive and hunger, pure need and hope. It's pure Alan. This is the song that answers the question Can The Alan Doyle Band rock? with an emphatically shouted Oh Yeah!
Lay Me Down is sublimely lovely, a sweetly sensual lovers' waltz.
Long past surrender, the bow'r sets the stage
With a single star spotlight where the deeds will be played
Our story's unscripted in this Secret Show
We'll draw back the curtains; we'll see where it goes...
With Alan on mandolin and Todd's accordion entwined with Kendel's fiddle, along with Alan's and Kendel's close harmonies, the sound and sense of the song come together and become as one.
My Day is sheer exuberance, matched with a willful determination to seize the day as one's own.
Let the sun shine, let it rain
I'm walking in good times, come what may
This is my day, no one can take it away
This is my day today
Backed by a bright, bouncy bass line and what can only be described as perky drums, this sounds the most "Great Big Sea-ish" of all the Boy On Bridge songs I've heard so far. And this is a Very Good Thing: If Alan is going to be genuinely free to express the full range of who he is and what he can do, the part of him that has excelled so brilliantly at being a part of GBS belongs in that expression too, as a significant part of the larger whole, an integral component of the Boy. It's also very smart to include on his solo album a song that feels reassuringly familiar to diehard GBS fans, a song that is also, along with It Ain't Enough, quite radio-play friendly.
Alan has achieved great things with GBS, unparalleled accomplishments, but every time I encounter someone who believes that these accomplishments make up the sum total of who he is and what he can do, I always think of it being much like somebody describing his physical appearance by saying "Alan Doyle has a spectacular right thigh." Which he most certainly does, quite spectacular indeed. And so is his left thigh...and his right arm...and his left...and his belly... And so on. My Day is a spectacular right-thigh of an Alan Doyle Song, made even more delicious in that while it sounds so thoroughly GBS, the subect matter could be seen as very much a statement about his own venturing out as a solo artist.
They filmed Break It Slow twice - this is the song during which there were equipment issues, with that gorgeous impromptu I Don't Mind Dancin' With You interlude in-between - and both times it was reminiscent of an acoustic Springsteen song (another Very Good Thing), especially these lines:
But I'll be okay,
Please don't delay
Do what you gotta do
This is a song about being left behind by the one you love - a song you can dance to. A song Alan dares you to resist dancing to. Absolutely Springsteen.
Light The Way is Alan's Hockey Dance Rocker, the Boy at his most eager and fierce, near-ready to burst with cocky excitement and pressing demand, shredding his Fender, striking his poses, and stealing the breath away from the bedazzled girl. Not to mention pounding her pulse. It's glorious, utterly so. And it is going to bring down the house at every single show he plays.
Alan at the piano, bold and brave and beautiful. I don't know the name of the lovely song he sang there - I'm calling it Heart Worth Breaking because of the power of that lyric to move the heart intent on loving.
Well, I've got a heart worth breaking
Would you like to take a try?
It's not something that I'm keen to
Openly advertise
The Boy when he is vulnerable is the Boy at his most appealing, his most lovable...his most real. And he looks so gorgeous playing that piano.
I first heard Rules Will All Be Broken on the laptop as a snippet from one of Alan's recording sessions with Mike Post. I was sitting in the Air Canada Lounge at Pearson when it claimed my heart, one of those unforgettable moments that you know beyond doubt will remain vivid and immediate in memory for the rest of your life. It was the moment I knew for sure that the long wait was going to be worth every day, every month, every year of its duration. And that the wait would eventually, finally, blissfully, reach its end. At Revival, hearing the full song for the first time, it felt like Arrival at the desired destination.
As long as Alan is writing songs this beautiful, this perfect - as beautiful and as perfect as he is - he'll continue making his own music. The only waiting left to do will be for More.
Where I Belong is a heart's anthem to Home, a song written for Alan's own Home that is going to resonate with all who have, for one reason or another, journeyed far away from the homes to which their own hearts will always belong. This song is Alan's gift to those hearts - solace and ache, sorrow and joy - and the circumstances that led to its appearance on Alan's first Solo Album have resulted in the song winding up exactly where it belongs.
I believe with all my heart that Newfoundlanders will be singing Alan's song a hundred years from now. I hope with all my heart that they'll be singing it at Home.
And that was the filming of Alan Doyle: Live At Revival, which will in a few short months be the first introduction, the First Hello, of Alan's new music to so many people, who are, I believe, going to be very impressed with what he has created. The album should follow soon after - the first album, that is - and then the live shows. As many as he can persuade/cajole/charm his new bandmates into playing.
This is the Beginning of the Beginning. Moving forward step-by-step on a never-before-travelled Brand New Road...the Road that leads from What Could Be to What Wonderfully Is.
Through the sunlight and the snow.