I'm stranded in Nashville
I'm a boy from Old Perlican
I went buskin' down Broadway
I made four bucks American
And I'm homesick and wishin'
I was still back home fishin'
But all of those times are gone
How strange to be in Tennessee
Singin' Newfoundland songs
I crossed over the border
'Neath the light from the stars
I had the luck of the Irish
I had my daddy's guitar
It was a Gibson J-45
Gonna keep me alive
And comfort me midnight till dawn
How strange to be in Tennessee
Singin' Newfoundland songs
I know it isn't Hank Williams
Tho' I can sing him as well
Sing Jimmie Rogers blue yodel
Sing Lefty Frizell
I'm a stranger here in Tennessee
I'm a boy from round the bay
Yeah, but I know how to sing, boys
I know how to play
Cause my daddy taught me
Taught me these words, Taught me these chords
Taught me before he passed on
How strange to be in Tennessee
Singin' Hard Hard Times
Singin' Kit on the Pond
Singin' Newfoundland songs
If there's one small consolation
Here in these desperate times
All these Nashville songwriters
Are all tryin' to look like Ron Hynes
How strange to be in Tennessee
Singin' Newfoundland songs - Ron Hynes , "Boy From Old Perlican"
This one is going to be hard to write, at least this first part. There were advantages to saying that it was because I was writing for a fan board that made me be less than honest about some things. For the one who made that "same review for the past year and a half" comment, I hope he knows that I change how I write for very few people, and that he is one of those very few.
The first time Great Big Sea played Nashville - at least, I think it was the first time - was during the spring 2003 tour with Carbon Leaf. The spring of 2003 was that brief, sweet interlude they themselves referred to on one of those recent podcasts as being a wonderful time of optimism and hope for GBS, when they felt like even with Darrell having left them, they would still be able to keep on being GBS, that they now had something very special with the five current band members, and that they would now be able to do and be whatever they wanted. That optimism and hope showed...this was the time when "Shines Right Through" was written about that very feeling, and it truly did shine through, brightly and clearly. It dazzled. This was the band I saw at the Exit/In on that warm spring night in Nashville.
Of course, as they themselves say on that same podcast a few seconds later, that moment passed. I witnessed its passing during the shows in the summer of 2003.
The next time they played Nashville, once again at the Exit/In, was in the fall of 2003, one of the first shows on the ill-fated Cowboy Mouth tour. The show itself teetered precariously on the edge of debacle. Most of the crowd disappeared as soon as Cowboy Mouth left the stage, and except for a half-dozen or so of The Faithful, the twenty or so others who remained for GBS seemed quite unimpressed. There was little hope or optimism to be found anywhere on the Exit/In's premises that night, though Alan did a valiant job of keeping the show on the rails, putting on a rousing performance and demanding the same of the others on stage with him, in spite of all else that was going on, in spite of the indifference of most of those in the crowd and in spite of what had to be a realisation that they had just embarked on what was going to be a very rough road. And then there was the fool up front who thought that it might make those up on that stage feel like at least someone thought them important if she kept taking pictures of them.
The fool who went back to her Nashville hotel room after the show, logged onto her laptop, and read the FTR that she had not had time to read before the show, the FTR she instantly knew would be the gift that never stopped giving. The fool who spent the next day in Nashville - the day before the College Station, Texas, show - wandering down Nashville's Street Of Dreams, the same Broadway that Ron Hynes and so many others have busked their way along, struggling to make what she knew was going to be a lasting decision.
That was the same day Alan and Gordie Sampson wrote Walk On The Moon, Lucky Me, and Let It Go in that single afternoon songwriting session.
When my bus rolled into town last night at 7 pm, it was the first time I had been in Nashville since another bus had rolled out of that town in the fall of 2003 as I headed for Texas, my lasting decision made.
Nashville resonates with history for me in other ways. There was a fan I met at the first Nashville show, a sweet girl I liked very much, who, by the time I saw her at the second Nashville show, was well on her way to becoming what I'll euphemistically call a "band girl," she and her friends having decided to do that which was required of them (or at least whatever they thought would be required of them) to work their way into that desperately-longed-for "in the entourage when we come to your backyard" status. I listened to them debate it all out, struggling to make their own lasting decision, at another show that took place between Nashville 1 and Nashville 2.
She's a little less of a sweet girl these days, too busy being cool and inside to be very sweet, though I do still like her, and it makes me sad that now when she stands up front at shows, she gets that "you aren't supposed to be up here anymore in the fan role if you want to hang with us in the band-girl role" look. Now she has her Temporary All-Access Pass stuck to her left tit, but the price she has paid for that access seems a high one to me- she's lost the joy of the music and the thrill of the performance. The first time I met her in Nashville, she was all in a breathless panic because she thought she would be too late in the lineup to be able to be up front by Alan. My husband and I made a space for her there, and we laughed at her relief and smiled when we saw how glad she was.
The last show I saw her at, she started out in the front, received her disapproving look from a crew member, and the last I saw of her, she was slinking around in the back by the sound booth, working on the logistics of the after-show activities, which now seem to be the real point of going to the shows. To each person their own lasting decisions, and I hope each person makes the decision that is best for them; but as for me, I miss that innocent fan I first met on a Nashville spring night in 2003.
I looked for her at Nashville this time, but didn't see her, though it looks as if the memory of her breathless panic and her heartfelt relief is going to haunt any and all future Nashville shows I see, restless ghosts walking 'neath the light of the Tennessee stars.
But I did wind up seeing a fellow who I had met at that post-first-Nashville College Station show, or, rather, was seen by him, since I didn't recall him at all, my memory of that show being blurred by the survivour-behaviour human coping response of forgetting much of that which is better forgotten. I have never run into anyone from that godawful show before this - the very few people there for GBS's opener mostly passionately detested their opening act equally as much as they frantically adored Cowboy Mouth's headlining act; the GBS band members played that opening set as if they were going to be taken out and shot immediately after wrapping it up; and I was still reeling from the expected aftereffects of that gift that was already well into the continuing-to-give process.
All I remembered about that show was hiding off to one side at a table and watching maybe 5 or 6 people standing out on the floor while GBS played, I remembered drinking about four too many rum & Diet Cokes, and I remembered talking to some local fellow and his displaced Newfoundlander buddy about football versus hockey. Hello, local fellow and hello, displaced Newfoundlander buddy at this third Nashville show, and though I would never have recognised either of them on my own, as soon as they nudged the memory, it all came back, whether I wanted it coming back or not, past again colliding with present.
The show itself, this Nashville show, the one in the present, their opening part of it, was swift and intense, as much music as they could possibly fit into the 45 minutes they had been allotted this time in Nashville. Their song choice was interesting, mostly "the hits" from years past (not a choice I agree with), with only one song from the new CD (Charlie Horse). Better was the inclusion of two of their best originals, Something Beautiful and When I Am King, both of which worked well to show their musical versatility. I don't take notes at shows anymore (a concession to the Distraction Factor problem), so the order might be off here, but this is more or less what they chose to play in Nashville:
recorded GBS Hove In Long Beach intro
Captain Kidd
Donkey Riding
When I'm Up
Something Beautiful
Charlie Horse
Lukey
Paddy Murphy
When I Am King
General Taylor
Scolding Wife
Helmethead
Consequence Free
Mari Mac
Ordinary Day
The cluster of GBS fans up front cheered the loudest for the usual suspects. As for those standing farther back with the bemused looks on their faces, I saw the most response to Lukey, Something Beautiful, When I Am King, Consequence Free and Ordinary Day. Nashville is a songwriters' town, and those there to see the headliner had come to see a fellow known as a very good wordsmith, so it didn't surprise me much which songs the "new people" reacted most to. I knew there was not a snowball's chance in hell it would happen, but I hoped for Let It Go all set long. There aren't many times I will come out and say "they should have done that song," but this is one of those times. They should have done that song, and introduced it as having been written there. I also kept hoping against hope to hear "Kit On The Pond," for Ron's sake.
Their performance itself was a little strained, I think in large part because they were trying to squeeze in as many songs in as possible at such a breakneck pace, and maybe even more because of how hard it is to change gears and play the Unknown Opener role in the middle of a months-long Evening-With-GBS tour, though once again Alan made a valiant effort to keep it all going, and this time he was helped by Bob, who did not look like he would rather be elsewhere for this show.
Facing a sparse crowd whose attention was far from being ready to focus on much more than grabbing a drink and socialising with friends is not the easiest of atmospheres in which to introduce yourself and your music, but as much of a challenge as it has to be at times, I love seeing GBS as the opener for crowds who have never heard them before. I love watching people hearing them for the very first time, seeing that look of wonder in the eyes of those who are touched and moved and delighted by their music and the way they perform it.
Playing these kinds of shows may not often fall within the parameters of "best business decisions" these days, not given the amount of money to be made at big festivals where they are a main draw and at shows aimed at the already-converted, but they are still going to be the shows that make the greatest impression on me, the shows where the magic they create is in its purest and sweetest and most innocent form, where no one is yet scheming to work their way "inside" and no one is yet expecting the band to provide them with their "happy fix". When it is all brand new, it does still shine right through, and I love the warmth and the brightness of that light, especially when I see it reflected in Alan's eyes.
After GBS left the stage, before Robert Earl Keen came on, I made like a "normal" GBS fan and promptly exited the premises (the difference being that I, unlike nearly all the others, came back in a bit to hear the other performer), heading out to grab a bite to eat, and then to take another walk down Nashville's Boulevard of Busking. I had two songs on my mind and my lips, Ron's Old Perlican, and Alan's Wallk Om The Moon, singing Newfoundland songs on Tennessee streets. I had the memory of the past and the worry of the present. And I had the hope of the future as well.
By the time I got back to the venue, their tour bus was loaded and gone, as were their fans. Robert Earl Keen was playing to his own enthusiastic fans. I stood back by the merch table, in the now-vacated area where Glenn had been set up with GBS's merch, watching the show, and a few people came up to me, asking about GBS, curious if they would be coming out and meeting with any fans, wondering if there were any CDs to buy, asking where were they from and what kind of music it was that they were playing.
I know the band has a very long haul to get to the next show in D.C. - long enough that when I decided to come back to Nashville to see this show, that meant I'd be skipping D.C. myself and heading straight to Boston later today - but I wish they'd stayed long enough to talk to some of these people. They gave up a day off to play this show, and for all that it was another sparse crowd during their time on stage - and a crowd that seemed a bit bemused by their music - they played that show well, and they caught the attention of some of those there in Nashville who were hearing them for the first time. I hope they know that. As hard as they work, they should always know when that hard work has paid off.
But then, chances are, those whose attention was caught will be back again, come Nashville 4, or College Station 2, or somewhere else down the road. My own moment of optimism and hope is nowhere near passing. I want Nashville to be the city Alan writes his Juno Songwriter Of The Year award-winning song in. I want to see Alan walk on the moon, and Nashville seems like a prime launching spot for that expedition. I want to hear more Newfoundland songs sung in Tennessee.
That was Nashville last night, the third show here in this town, third time thinking about how strange it was to be hearing Newfoundland songs in this place, hearing the same songs while the past and present were getting all tangled up with each other, what was and what is, what could have been and what might possibly be. If it's true that the third time is a charm, I'm wondering just what spell it is that might be cast with that charm, just what kind of magic might be there for the making and what new history lessons might lie ahead for the learning.